Can you get sick from eating expired uncrustables?

In this brief guide, we will answer the question, “Can you get sick from eating expired uncrustables?” We will also discuss how to tell if uncrustable have gone bad and whether uncrustables need to be refrigerated.

Can you get sick from eating expired uncrustables?

Yes, you can get sick from eating expired uncrustables especially if it has been long since the expiry date has passed. Eating expired uncrustables can be accompanied by symptoms like diarrhea, vomiting, and nausea. 

Moreover, expired uncrustables lose their texture because of the bread present in them. Other ingredients present such as jelly filling and peanut butter can also cause the symptoms experienced after consuming uncrustables.

Do uncrustables go bad?

Yes, uncrustables eventually go bad like most foods containing sandwiches, especially if not properly stored. If not well stored, uncrustables tend to become inedible because they develop molds and bacteria that are hazardous if consumed.

Proper storage of uncrustables such as storing them in an airtight container, away from direct sunlight, and storing them in a dry and cool area can help in elongating the shelf life of uncrustables.

How can you tell if uncrustables have gone bad?

The first sign that uncrustables have gone bad is a rancid smell. They tend to emit an off-putting smell that can be said to be similar to that of Putty. Smelly uncrustables should be discarded.

The color change can also be an indication of spoilage. With time expired, uncrustables tend to become dull or dark in color. Dark and greenish fuzzy substances are also signs of mold growth and should be discarded.

How long do uncrustables last?

Uncrustables last for two weeks on average.  The shelf life is dependent on the type of filling used and the type of bread also used. Once uncrustables are opened and exposed to the air, their shelf life decreases because it becomes less fatty and dries out quickly. After opening, it is best to consume it within two days.

Storing uncrustables in the refrigerator helps them keep for a long time, that is four to five days. It is however not necessary to refrigerate uncrustables because most sandwiches are best consumed two days after adding other ingredients and fillings.

What are the tips for proper storage of uncrustables?

Uncrustables should be stored in a dry and cool place. You can store them in the pantry especially if you plan to consume them within four days. If you intend to store it for a month, you can store uncrustables in the freezer. 

Uncrustable can be stored in the freezer for up to  6 months. When freezing uncrustables, you should use foil or plastic wrap to help in keeping them longer.


In this brief guide, we have answered the question, “Can you get sick from eating expired uncrustables?” We have also discussed how to tell if uncrustables have gone bad and how to properly store uncrustables.

Hope you find this blog useful, in case of any questions please let us know


Leave a Comment